Can You Substitute Olive Oil For Vegetable Oil In A Cake Or Not?

When baking a cake, there is often debate about which type of oil is best. People have always wondered, “Can olive oil be substituted for vegetable oil in a cake?”

The short answer is Yes, but there is a catch, which is why you should read this article. Here you will find the answers you look for when it comes to the best oil to use for baking, why it is the best, and whether it is good for you.

What is olive oil?

Olives, the olive tree’s fruit, are used to make olive oil. An ancient Mediterranean crop, olives are made by pressing whole olives.

Olive oil is used in soaps, medicine, cosmetics, cooking, and traditional lamp fuel. The Mediterranean-born olive oil is now well-known all over the world.

There is a lot of olive oil used in the Mediterranean diet. It has many antioxidants. Monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs), which are regarded as healthy by experts, are the main source of fat in them.

The antioxidants in olive oil may shield cells from cellular deterioration, thereby preventing several illnesses and conditions.

The least processed olive oil, extra virgin, has a sour aftertaste but has more antioxidant properties than other varieties due to its minimal processing.

What is vegetable oil?

Edible plant oils are also known as vegetable oils. Chemical solvents as well as crushing or squeezing the plants or seeds are used to extract the oil.

In addition to cooking and baking, they can be discovered in packaged foods such as salad dressings, margarine, mayonnaise, and cookies.

Common vegetable oils include soybean oil, sunflower oil, groundnut oil, and coconut oil.

Finely tuned vegetable oils did not become usable until the twentieth century when extraction technology improved.

These are extracted from plants with the help of solutes or an oil mill. They are regularly purified, refined, and in some cases, chemically altered after that.

Health-conscious consumers prefer oils made by grinding up or mashing plants or seeds to those made with chemicals.

Can you substitute olive oil for vegetable oil in a cake?

You can, indeed. Olive is close to vegetable oil. When substituting vegetable oil (or another cooking oil) for olive oil in a baking recipe, you can use a 1-to-1 ratio. The distinct taste of olive oil may influence the baked good’s flavor.

Can you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil in cookies?

Absolutely. When used to make cakes and cookies, olive oil has a delicate and distinctive flavor.

Olive oil’s citrusy aroma can enhance other flavors like chocolate, nuts, spices, and fruit, which are frequently present in baked goods.

However, take care to prevent the flavor of the olive oil from overpowering the rest of the meal.

SEE: Is Olive Oil Flammable?

Can you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil in muffins?

Yes, you can. Baked goods with a fruity, nutty, or savory flavor, like my delectable pumpkin bread, work best when made with olive oil.

It gains a rich moistness and depth from the olive oil that enhances the warm spices and harmonizes beautifully with the flavor of honey and the topping of pumpkin seeds.

Can you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil in brownies?

You can, indeed. Because olive oil has the same intensity as other oils, you can easily replace it in brownie recipes without having to adjust the measurements or make any conversions. Olive oil can, however, alter the flavor of the brownies.

Can you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil in carrot cake?

Yes, particularly if the recipe says for whole wheat flour instead of all-purpose; however, if you only have all-purpose, you can still use it.

It calls for mild extra-virgin olive oil rather than refined vegetable oil, producing a wonderfully moist cake free of odd flavors.

SEE: Does Canola Oil Go Bad?

What happens if you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil?

If you switch vegetable oil to olive oil, nothing will happen. Even so, you must be certain you use the proper amount of olive oil because this oil has a distinct flavor that could affect how the baked good tastes.

What is the best olive oil you can substitute for vegetable oil when baking cakes?

Different olives produce various types of olive oil. But the best for baking is the small and distinctively sweet Arbequina olives.

9 amazing substitutes for vegetable oil in cake mix

In your baked goods, the following can be used in place of vegetable oil.

1. A plain applesauce

A purée made of apples is known as apple sauce or applesauce. Peeled or unpeeled, apples can be used, and they can be spiced or sweetened. In a cake mix, it works very well as a vegetable oil substitute.

2. Melted butter

When vegetable oil is called for, butter may be used in place. Butter will smooth out your cake batter and give it a fluffy texture when baked.

3. Cooked, pureed, and unseasoned cauliflower

Cauliflower is one of many vegetables that make up the species Brassica oleracea of the genus Brassica and the family Brassicaceae.

Cauliflower is a plant that contains a lot of oil, and since vegetable oil is simply edible plant oil, it serves as a suitable replacement.

4. Ghee

Indian clarified butter known as ghee is produced by perusing the milk solids from melted butter. It is a great substitute and would work just like regular butter. It is often used in Middle Eastern and Indian cuisine, among other cuisines.

SEE: Does Oil Evaporate?

5. Melted margarine

Another excellent substitute for vegetable oil is margarine. It will have similar miraculous effects to that of butter in your cake mix.

6. Mayonnaise

Emulsifying eggs, oil, and a type of acid—typically vinegar or lemon juice—lead to the creation of mayonnaise.

Emulsification is the process of combining two or more liquids that wouldn’t normally mix. They make a fantastic substitute for vegetable oil because of their composition.

Eggs, oil, and other ingredients that you would typically use when baking is already present and must be added to your cake mix.

7. Sour cream

A dairy product known as sour cream is produced by fermenting regular cream with specific lactic acid bacteria.

If used properly, the bacterial culture, which is added either intentionally or naturally, sours and thickens the cream, making it an excellent alternative for baking ingredients.

8. Vegetable shortening

Typically, vegetable oils like soybean, cottonseed, or corn that have been hydrogenated or partially hydrogenated are used to make vegetable shortening. You can also use this as an alternative.

9. Yogurt

Yogurt, a dairy product that will completely change the way your baking feels, involves fermenting milk with yogurt culture. It offers calcium and protein, and it might improve good gut flora.


What does olive oil do to cake mix?

In a cake mix, olive oil is acceptable. It transforms your cake into what a cake ought to be: soft, moist, and spongy.

When substituting olive oil for butter or vegetable oil, be sure to take any flavor variations that may occur into consideration.

SEE: Get a $2 off $5 Coupon at Savers Supermarket

Is canola vegetable oil?

A vegetable-based oil with a wide range of uses is canola oil. Due to worries about its adverse effects and production practices, many people have cut canola oil from their diets. But when properly processed, the oil is very healthy.

Is olive oil good for baking?

By using olive oil, you can bake with less saturated fat and “bad” cholesterol. It is regarded as “good” fat, as opposed to butter.

Additionally, it boosts the amount of vitamin E and antioxidants in your baked goods, offering your desserts a cardio boost. Antioxidants are natural substances that shield our cells.


Vegetable oils are comestible oils derived from plants, and olive oil is inferred first from the plant seed of olives, which could also be classified as vegetable oil but for their distinct flavor.

As a result, you can swap olive oil for vegetable oil, but you must ensure that the oil is labeled for the baking you intend to avoid the essential nature of the olive oil overpowering your cake or baked good.

Aside from that, there are many great alternatives to vegetable oil mentioned in this article that you can try in place of it.

Thanks for reading.

If you enjoyed reading this article, view Cheffist for more.