Is Wendy’s Frosty Ice Cream or Milkshake?

If you’ve ever patronized any Wendy’s restaurant, you sure have heard about their tasty frosty. One thing about the frosty that remains puzzling is its classification. The malty, thick, and frozen desserts melt so well that you might just want to call a frosty an ice cream.

At the same time, it’s as light as a milkshake. Regardless, the frosty is a delicious dessert that some adults would rather have for lunch on a hot afternoon instead of a tasty burger and fries.

Maybe you’re one of those who only cared about enjoying a delicious frozen treat rather than knowing what it is exactly. However, in this article, you’ll get to know what Wendy’s frosty is.

What is a frosty?

A frosty is a trademark frozen treat sold at Wendy’s. This frozen treat started in 1969 and has since then remained all through the years. The frosty was and is still part of the original Wendy’s menu alongside hamburgers, chili, fries, and soft drinks.

Wendy’s frosty is a thick but light, cold, and creamy dessert served in a bright yellow and red cup and eaten with a spoon. Furthermore, Wendy’s frosty was an original chocolate flavor but now has a vanilla variant alongside toppings like Oreos, M&Ms, and cookie dough.

Additionally, the main ingredients in Wendy’s frosty are milk, cream, cocoa, and sugar. Other ingredients include guar gum, corn syrup, cellulose gum, vitamin A palmitate, natural vanilla flavor, carrageenan, monoglycerides, diglycerides, calcium sulfate, sodium citrate, and dextrose.

Is Wendy’s frosty an ice cream?

No, it is not. Although the frosty looks and may taste like ice cream, it is not. The frosty contains a lower amount of milkfat when compared to the amount in ice creams. In addition, some people have compared it to a soft serve ice cream but a frosty is softer.

SEE: How to Get Free Food At Wendy’s

Is Wendy’s frosty a milkshake?

No, it is not. The frosty may have the light texture and creamy taste of a milkshake but it is not. Instead, think of it as a combination of a milkshake and an ice cream.

Is Wendy’s frosty a drink?

Wendy’s frosty is not a drink but a frozen dessert. Moreover, it has a thick texture that works best with a spoon instead of a straw.

SEE: Check Out Wendy’s Allergen Menu Here

How much dairy is in Wendy’s frosty?

Wendy’s frosty contains 4% milkfat which does not suffice to make it ice cream.

Is Wendy’s frosty healthy?

Wendy’s frosty is a delicious treat that you should eat in moderation because of its high-calorie content. The nutritional value varies with the amount of frosty you’re eating and the toppings you add. A medium-sized original chocolate frosty (16 oz. cup) contains:

  • 393 calories
  • 7.7g total fat
  • 70g carbohydrates
  • 10g protein
  • 9.8g dietary fiber
  • 292mg sodium
  • 48mg cholesterol
  • 551mg potassium
  • 3.1mg iron
  • Other vitamins and minerals

Can you make Wendy’s frosty at home?

Wendy’s did not make their frosty’s recipe public but there are copycat recipes that you can follow to make yourself the delicious frozen dessert at home.

SEE: Can You Melt Frosting for Cake Pops Without Ruining It?

How to make a copycat of Wendy’s frosty

a glass of chocolate frosty - cheffist

This copycat recipe makes up to 10 cups of frosty.


  • 1 ½ cups of frozen cool whip
  • 6 teaspoons of condensed milk
  • 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract
  • 5 cups of 1% chocolate milk


  • Put all the ingredients into a blender
  • Then, blend until you have a smooth texture
  • Pour the creamy mixture into a freezer-safe container and freeze it for up to three hours
  • Every 45 minutes, bring out the creamy mixture and whisk it until it is smooth and exactly like Wendy’s frosty
  • When the time is up, bring it out of the freezer and serve it in cups
  • Add a topping like whipped cream, sprinkles, Oreos, chocolate syrup, chocolate chips, or whipped cool whip

SEE: Enjoy These Creamy Treats On The Sonic Ice Cream Menu


Is Wendy’s frosty gluten-free?

Yes, it is. All the frosty flavors at Wendy’s do not contain any gluten ingredients. Therefore, they are 100% gluten-free.

How much does Wendy’s frosty cost?

The cost of Wendy’s frosty is based on the size and the type of frosty you’re having and your location. The average price of a small cup of frosty is $0.99, a medium is $1.99, and a large cup is $2.29.

Is Wendy’s frosty halal?

Wendy’s frosty does not have halal certification. However, it does not contain any ingredient that is not halal. So, it could be safe to have a cup of frosty but you do need to be careful.


If you have always called Wendy’s frosty an ice cream or a milkshake, you’re not alone. Think of a frosty as an ice cream chimera or a mix of ice cream and a milkshake.

In texture and taste, the yellow and red cup of deliciousness gives you a balance of both an ice cream and a milkshake. Now that you know what a frosty is, go ahead to enjoy your cup – from a Wendy’s restaurant or a copycat version.

Thanks for reading.

Visit Cheffist to get all the information you need about your favorite items in your favorite restaurants.