Here’s Why Your Sugar Cookie Dough Is Too Dry [+ 6 Ways To Fix It]

Is your sugar cookie dough too dry? Are you holding your head in your hands, wondering where it all went wrong? You’re not alone.

Many home bakers and confectionery experts have also struggled with this problem. In this article, I’ll explain why your sugar cookie dough is too dry — as well as give you some tips and tricks that can help you solve this issue.

But first, let’s start by taking a quick look at what sugar cookie dough is.

SEE: Here’s How To Store Biscuits To Keep Them Crisp

What is sugar cookie dough?

Sugar cookie dough is the dough used for making sugar cookies. It’s a mixture of flour (usually all-purpose), sugar, butter, eggs, and baking powder.

Flour and sugar are the main ingredients in sugar cookie dough. Butter and eggs are added to give the dough richness and make it softer. And the baking powder is added to make the dough rise and give it structure.

The resulting dough is then rolled out into a flat sheet, cut into cookie-sized pieces, and baked until golden brown. Sugar cookies are often decorated with icing, sprinkles, or chocolate chips, to give them extra flavor and texture.

Why is your sugar cookie dough too dry?

The reason why your sugar cookie dough is too dry may be because you’re using too much flour or baking powder. When you use too much flour or baking powder, your dough will turn out dry and extremely stiff.

Another reason why your sugar cookie dough is too dry may be because you’ve over-mixed it. When you over-mix cookie dough, the gluten in the flour develops more and more, causing the dough to become very dry.

To prevent this issue, make sure to use an electric mixer with a paddle attachment. If you don’t have an electric mixer, you can use a whisk or a wooden spoon instead. Just be sure to mix the dough for no longer than five minutes.

SEE: Are There Chocolate Chip Cookies Without Brown Sugar?

How to fix dry sugar cookie dough

1. Add more water

If your sugar cookie dough is too dry, add some water. Start with about 1/4 cup, then gradually increase it until you reach a good consistency for rolling out the dough and shaping it into cookies.

2. Add milk or yogurt

Milk and yogurt add moisture and flavor to the dough, so you can try using any of them if your sugar cookie dough is too dry. If using yogurt, add it gradually and mix thoroughly until the dough reaches your desired consistency.

3. Use more eggs

Crack two eggs or three into a bowl, then mix them into the sugar cookie dough. The eggs will add more moisture and volume to the dough, thereby changing its consistency.

4. Add more butter

If you want your cookie dough to be moist, add more butter to it and mix until it’s fully absorbed. Make sure you’re using melted butter and not cold butter. Cold butter will make your dough drier, which is what you want to avoid.

5. Add oil

If you don’t like any of the above options, try adding some oil to your cookie dough to help soften it and make it easier to work with. Add about five tablespoons of oil to each batch of dough and mix until you’ve combined the ingredients well.

6. Add melted chocolate chips

If oil doesn’t work, then you might need to try this option. Simply melt some chocolate chips in a microwave for 30 seconds or until they are completely melted. Then stir the melted chocolate chips into the rest of your dough mixture before baking.

SEE: What Happens if You Eat Raw Dough?

Why is your cookie dough too sticky?

There are a few reasons why cookie dough is too sticky. The first is that it’s too cold. Cookie dough should be at room temperature, so if you’ve stored it in the fridge or freezer, it will get sticky.

Sticky cookie dough can also be a result of using too much flour. A little extra flour is ok, but if you add too much flour, your dough will be sticky and difficult to work with.

Finally, sticky cookie dough can be a sign of overmixing. Overmixing your dough can result in more gluten formation than desired, making it overly sticky.

If your cookie dough is too sticky, then you should try adding more liquids such as water, milk, and eggs to your dough.

What should the consistency of cookie dough be?

Cookie dough should have a smooth, slightly sticky consistency. It should also be moist but stiff enough to hold its shape when you cut it into shapes with a knife or spoon.

If the dough is too wet or sticky, it will be difficult to work with and will likely result in a raw doughy center when you bake it.

You can tell if your cookie dough has reached the right consistency by examining it with your fingers. The dough should have a slight resistance when you run your finger through it. This means it’s not too dry but has just enough moisture to make it flexible.

SEE: Can You Make Dough With Just Flour And Water?

What to do with dry cookies

Mix them with other foods

If you have dry cookies, you can chop them up and mix them with other foods, such as potatoes or carrots, to create an interesting snack. You can also add chopped dry cookies to meatloaf, meatballs, and other ground meats to give them extra flavor and texture.

Make a snack mix

If you want something more interesting, try combining dry cookies with pretzels, breadsticks, and other snack items in a large bowl. You can also add some dried fruit and nuts to this mix. Your family will love it.

Use them as toppings

This is another easy way to repurpose dry cookies. Just crush the cookies and spread them on cupcakes, ice-creams, or cakes for extra texture and flavor. You can also add nuts and sprinkles if you want.

Make a pudding

Dry cookies also work well for making puddings. Simply crush all the cookies and add them to your pudding ingredients. Once you have your pudding ready, top it with some chocolate chips or caramel chips for extra crunch and flavor.

SEE: Is Pudding Gluten-Free and Good for Celiacs?


What are sugar cookies?

Sugar cookies are cookies that contain flour and sugar as their main ingredients. You can make them yourself or buy them from grocery stores and supermarkets. Some restaurants like McAlister’s Deli also give their customers sugar cookies for free.

What should you do if your cookie dough is too wet?

Add more flour. If your cookie dough is too wet, add more flour and mix thoroughly. If you don’t have enough flour, add cornstarch to the dough. Cornstarch will soak up any excess moisture in the dough and make it easier to work with.

Can you make cookies at home?

Yes, you can. The best part about making your cookies at home is that you can control the ingredients. For example, if you have diabetes or other sugar sensitivity issues, you can easily substitute sugar for another sweetener or even leave it out altogether if you prefer.


Sugar cookie dough is just what it sounds like- it’s a mixture of sugar, flour, butter, and eggs that you can use to make sugar cookies.

If your sugar cookie dough is too dry, try adding 1/4 cup of water (or more) to the dough. You can also try adding other liquid ingredients such as eggs, milk, yogurt, melted butter or chocolate chips, and oil.

Thanks for reading.

Visit Cheffist to learn more about cookie dough.